NomHealthier fast food

Five Guys

Coffee Milkshake

The Five Guys Coffee Milkshake has 558 calories, with 10.5g protein, 73g carbs, 66g sugar, and 422mg sodium.

Our total of Five Guys' official per-portion figures (November 2026): Vanilla Shake Base + Coffee + Whipped Cream (Supplier S).

Calories
558
Protein
10.5g
Carbs
73g
Sodium
422mg

Vanilla shake base, the coffee mix-in and whipped cream.

VegetarianNo wheat listed

Nom Score

45/100
D

Low on nutrients. Great sodium. Watch the sat fat & sugar. Light on fiber & protein.

Allergens
Milk

Five Guys: “Peanuts are served in all Five Guys restaurants, but none of our menu items contain tree nuts.”

Five Guys: “Our potatoes are freshly cut, soaked in water and ONLY fried in refined peanut oil using fryers that cook absolutely nothing else.”

Five Guys: “Our food is made to order by hand in kitchens that handle the noted allergens, so there is always a risk of cross-contact between ingredients.”

Five Guys: “Please be aware that our bread does contain gluten, so there is always a risk for cross-contamination.”

See the full Five Guys allergen menu →

Portion check

How much is this, really?

Almost a full meal
Pretty filling — maybe add a small side if you're extra hungry
15

1 × 558 cal = 558 cal

Here's what this means for your daily nutrition

18%
Sodium422mg
85%
Sat Fat17g
132%
Sugar66g

Rich in sat fat and sugar. An occasional treat, maybe.

By the numbers

Nutrition & Nom Score

Nutrition Facts
Calories
558

% Daily Value*

Total Fat
27g35%
Saturated Fat
17g85%
Trans Fat
0g
Cholesterol
101mg34%
Sodium
422mg18%
Total Carbohydrates
73g27%
Dietary Fiber
<1g2%
Total Sugars
66g
Protein
10.5g21%

* The % Daily Value tells you how much a nutrient in a serving of food contributes to a daily diet. 2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice.

Nom Score BreakdownD
Score capped — low nutritional value
Nutrients to watch
Sodium
75.6 mg/100cal
← Best
excellentTarget: <= 100
Sat Fat
3.0 g/100cal
← Best
poorTarget: <= 1
Sugar
11.8 g/100cal
← Best
poorTarget: <= 1
Portion size
Portion
558 cal
← Best
moderateTarget: <= 400 cal
Good stuff
Fiber
0.1 g/100cal
Best →
poorTarget: >= 1.4
Protein
1.9 g/100cal
Best →
poorTarget: >= 6
Nom Score measures nutrition per calorie. Weights: Sodium (30%), Sugar (25%), Sat Fat (20%), Portion (10%), Fiber (10%), Protein (5%).

What's inside

Ingredients

Vanilla Shake Base
Milkfat And Nonfat Milk, Sugar, Whey, Contains Less Than 1% Of: Mono and Diglycerides, Cellulose Gum, Tetrasodium Pyrophosphate, Carrageenan, Natural And Artificial Flavors. Contains: Milk
Coffee
Water, Coffee, Caramel Color (Contains Sulfites), Salt, Natural Flavor, Citric Acid, Benzoic Acid as a Preservative.
Whipped Cream (Supplier S)
Cream, Milk, Sugar, Sorbitol, Nonfat Milk, Contains Less Than 1% of: Mono and Diglycerides, Carrageenan, Artificial Flavor, Polysorbate 80, Mixed Tocopherols (Vitamin E) to Protect Flavor. Propellant: Nitrous Oxide. Contains: Milk
Whipped Cream (Supplier A)
Cream, Skim Milk, Corn Syrup, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Mono and Diglycerides, Carrageenan, Dextrose, Natural and Artificial Vanilla Flavor, Nitrous Oxide as Whipping Propellant. Contains: Milk

Frequently asked questions

Is the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake healthy?

The Five Guys Coffee Milkshake earns a Nom Score of D (45/100). Low on nutrients. Great sodium. Watch the sat fat & sugar. Light on fiber & protein.

How many calories are in the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake?

The Five Guys Coffee Milkshake has 558 calories, with 10.5g protein, 73g carbs, 66g sugar, and 422mg sodium.

What is in the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake?

The Five Guys Coffee Milkshake is made from 4 components: Vanilla Shake Base, Coffee, Whipped Cream (Supplier S), Whipped Cream (Supplier A). The full ingredient list for each is shown on this page.

Is the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake gluten-free?

The allergen information for the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake lists no wheat, with no “may contain” or shared-equipment note for it, and its ingredients name no other gluten grain. Five Guys says: “Please be aware that our bread does contain gluten, so there is always a risk for cross-contamination.”

Is the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake vegetarian or vegan?

The Five Guys Coffee Milkshake is marked vegetarian (but not vegan) at Five Guys.

Does the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake contain artificial additives?

The Five Guys Coffee Milkshake lists 3 commonly-flagged additives: high-fructose corn syrup, caramel color, artificial flavor.

What is the Nom Score of the Five Guys Coffee Milkshake?

It scores D — below average. The Nom Score grades every item A–F on nutritional quality per calorie (sodium, sugar, saturated fat, fiber, protein, and portion size).

Cite or link to this page

Writing about this? Grab a ready-made citation or a link to embed.

Citation
Nom. "Coffee Milkshake Nutrition & Nom Score." Nom, 2026, https://nom.now/five-guys/five-guys-coffee-shake.
Embed link
<a href="https://nom.now/five-guys/five-guys-coffee-shake">Coffee Milkshake Nutrition & Nom Score — Nom Score</a>